← Back to New York

Elm Lake Area Fishing Spots

174 Fishing Spots New York

Anglers exploring the Elm Lake Area Fishing Spots in New York will discover 174 fishing destinations spanning 108 well-stocked lakes and 66 productive reservoirs. This region is particularly noted for its Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish fisheries, drawing both local enthusiasts and traveling anglers.

What makes this zone special is the variety of fishing experiences available within a short drive. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Whether you prefer fly fishing in moving water or casting topwater lures on a calm lake, this area has you covered.

Whether you're a bass tournament competitor or a family looking for a relaxed panfish outing, the waters in this zone accommodate every angling style. Power fishing with reaction baits covers water quickly on the larger lakes, while finesse techniques shine in the smaller, pressured waters. Don't overlook catfishing opportunities here — prepared baits and chicken liver produce excellent channel catfish action from spring through fall.

Anglers traveling to the Elm Lake Area Fishing Spots will find a range of amenities nearby. Bait and tackle shops, convenience stores, and gas stations are available in the surrounding communities. For the best experience, arrive early to secure parking at popular spots — especially on weekends during peak season. Pack sunscreen, insect repellent, and plenty of water, as some locations offer limited shade. A New York fishing license must be purchased before your trip and carried while fishing.

All 174 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (108)

Algonquian Waters Lake

📍 41.0593, -74.3700
View full guide →

Banks Pond

📍 41.2654, -74.5018
View full guide →

Barry Lakes

📍 41.1948, -74.4421
View full guide →

Barry Lakes

📍 41.2001, -74.4369
View full guide →

Bear Swamp Lake

📍 41.0367, -74.3642
View on Maps ↗

Bogue Pond

📍 41.0138, -74.3352
View on Maps ↗

Boy Scout Lake

📍 41.0742, -74.3469
View on Maps ↗

Brushwood Pond

📍 41.1040, -74.2329
View on Maps ↗

Cannonball Lake

📍 41.0870, -74.2281
View on Maps ↗

Cliffwood Lake

📍 41.1077, -74.4796
View on Maps ↗

Cold Spring Lake

📍 41.0144, -74.3514
View on Maps ↗

Conrad Pond

📍 41.0170, -74.2247
View on Maps ↗

Crystal Lake

📍 41.0333, -74.2405
View on Maps ↗

Cupsaw Lake

📍 41.1169, -74.2493
View on Maps ↗

Dogwood Pond

📍 41.0302, -74.4893
View on Maps ↗

Duck Pond

📍 41.1138, -74.2397
View on Maps ↗

East Highland Lake

📍 41.1724, -74.4532
View on Maps ↗

Elm Lake

📍 41.3994, -74.5478
View on Maps ↗

Finan's Pond

📍 41.3986, -74.3262
View on Maps ↗

Gatun Pond

📍 41.1088, -74.2310
View on Maps ↗

Genaders Pond

📍 41.0504, -74.3841
View on Maps ↗

Gordon Lakes

📍 41.0535, -74.3621
View on Maps ↗

Gordon Lakes

📍 41.0562, -74.3612
View on Maps ↗

Great Gorge Lake

📍 41.1618, -74.5210
View on Maps ↗

Green Pond

📍 41.0050, -74.4953
View on Maps ↗

Green Turtle Pond

📍 41.1462, -74.3294
View on Maps ↗

Hanks Pond

📍 41.0828, -74.4368
View on Maps ↗

Harrison Mountain Lake

📍 41.1064, -74.3179
View on Maps ↗

Hawthorne Lake

📍 41.0575, -74.5898
View on Maps ↗

Heaters Pond

📍 41.0717, -74.5854
View on Maps ↗

Hidden Valley Lake

📍 41.0727, -74.2789
View on Maps ↗

High Crest Lake

📍 41.0202, -74.3744
View on Maps ↗

Hill Lake

📍 41.3040, -74.3394
View on Maps ↗

Hird Lake

📍 41.0403, -74.3872
View on Maps ↗

Hoot Owl Lake

📍 41.0008, -74.4042
View on Maps ↗

Iaoapogh Lake

📍 41.0900, -74.2292
View on Maps ↗

Indian Trail Lake

📍 41.0619, -74.3691
View on Maps ↗

Kearfott Lake

📍 41.0179, -74.3044
View on Maps ↗

Kitchell Lake

📍 41.0893, -74.3539
View on Maps ↗

Kloibers Pond

📍 41.2675, -74.2122
View on Maps ↗

Kohout Lake

📍 41.1925, -74.3938
View on Maps ↗

Korby Lake

📍 41.3952, -74.2489
View on Maps ↗

Lake Iosco

📍 41.0307, -74.3214
View on Maps ↗

Lake Kampfe

📍 41.0320, -74.3463
View on Maps ↗

Lake Lookout

📍 41.1568, -74.4347
View on Maps ↗

Lake Maratanz

📍 41.3814, -74.5953
View on Maps ↗

Lake Maratanz

📍 41.3838, -74.5931
View on Maps ↗

Lake Tamarack

📍 41.0507, -74.2439
View on Maps ↗

Lake Vreeland

📍 41.0631, -74.2400
View on Maps ↗

Lake Wanda

📍 41.1819, -74.4534
View on Maps ↗

Lake Wildwood

📍 41.1525, -74.5240
View on Maps ↗

Laurel Lake

📍 41.1458, -74.4758
View on Maps ↗

Leeper Pond

📍 41.1541, -74.3939
View on Maps ↗

Little Cedar Pond

📍 41.1805, -74.2762
View on Maps ↗

Livingston Ponds

📍 41.2057, -74.4336
View on Maps ↗

Livingston Ponds

📍 41.2119, -74.4380
View on Maps ↗

Lokenhurst Pond

📍 41.3276, -74.5506
View on Maps ↗

Lookover Lake

📍 41.1475, -74.4043
View on Maps ↗

Louemma Lake

📍 41.2575, -74.4971
View on Maps ↗

Lower Morse Lake

📍 41.0217, -74.3163
View on Maps ↗

Lower Mount Glen Lake

📍 41.0775, -74.3649
View on Maps ↗

Lower Twin Lake

📍 41.0159, -74.2978
View on Maps ↗

Matos Lake

📍 41.1775, -74.5061
View on Maps ↗

Matthews Lake

📍 41.0503, -74.3617
View on Maps ↗

Mirror Lake

📍 41.0312, -74.2330
View on Maps ↗

Misty Pond

📍 41.0057, -74.4334
View on Maps ↗

Mombasha Lake

📍 41.2814, -74.2062
View on Maps ↗

Mountain Lake

📍 41.1806, -74.5000
View on Maps ↗

Mountain Springs Lake

📍 41.0378, -74.3822
View on Maps ↗

Oakwood Lake

📍 41.0135, -74.3391
View on Maps ↗

Parker Lake

📍 41.1997, -74.3952
View on Maps ↗

Pinecliff Lake

📍 41.1311, -74.3749
View on Maps ↗

Pinecrest Lake

📍 41.1015, -74.3861
View on Maps ↗

Placid Pond

📍 41.3157, -74.2182
View on Maps ↗

Potake Pond

📍 41.1358, -74.2140
View on Maps ↗

Private Pond (45 Glenwood Mt Road)

📍 41.2577, -74.5145
View on Maps ↗

Rainbow Lake

📍 41.0303, -74.3049
View on Maps ↗

Ryker Lake

📍 41.0522, -74.5495
View on Maps ↗

Saffin Pond

📍 41.0057, -74.5871
View on Maps ↗

Sawmill Pond

📍 41.1249, -74.4991
View on Maps ↗

Scarletelli Pond

📍 41.0702, -74.2801
View on Maps ↗

Serpentine Lake

📍 41.2481, -74.2308
View on Maps ↗

Seymour's Pond

📍 41.2121, -74.3736
View on Maps ↗

Shady Lake

📍 41.0490, -74.3678
View on Maps ↗

Shepherd Lake

📍 41.1375, -74.2266
View on Maps ↗

Skyline Lakes

📍 41.0720, -74.2729
View on Maps ↗

Smith Pond

📍 41.0133, -74.2490
View on Maps ↗

Smith Pond

📍 41.0117, -74.2342
View on Maps ↗

South Twin Lake

📍 41.0118, -74.2971
View on Maps ↗

Sterling Lake

📍 41.2069, -74.2588
View on Maps ↗

Sunset Lake

📍 41.0546, -74.3863
View on Maps ↗

Surprise Lake

📍 41.1854, -74.3469
View on Maps ↗

Terrace Pond

📍 41.1390, -74.3947
View on Maps ↗

Timberbrook Pond

📍 41.0125, -74.4593
View on Maps ↗

Todd Lake

📍 41.0476, -74.2413
View on Maps ↗

Tuxedo Lake

📍 41.1961, -74.2100
View on Maps ↗

Twilinger Lake

📍 41.0198, -74.3108
View on Maps ↗

Upper East Highland Lake

📍 41.1642, -74.4552
View on Maps ↗

Upper Erskine Lake

📍 41.0974, -74.2460
View on Maps ↗

Upper Highland Lake

📍 41.1799, -74.4670
View on Maps ↗

Upper Morse Lake

📍 41.0190, -74.3166
View on Maps ↗

Van Nostrand Lake

📍 41.0360, -74.3741
View on Maps ↗

Vernon Valley Lake

📍 41.2281, -74.4866
View on Maps ↗

Warwick Lake

📍 41.2757, -74.4019
View on Maps ↗

West Pond

📍 41.1848, -74.3535
View on Maps ↗

Weyble Pond

📍 41.1123, -74.2262
View on Maps ↗

White Rock Lake

📍 41.0346, -74.5165
View on Maps ↗

Zeliff Pond

📍 41.0449, -74.3670
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (66)

Baker Pond

📍 41.0058, -74.2224
View full guide →

Bear Swamp Lake

📍 41.0969, -74.2173
View on Maps ↗

Blue Lake

📍 41.1632, -74.2602
View on Maps ↗

Canistear Reservoir

📍 41.1217, -74.4847
View on Maps ↗

Cantys Lake

📍 41.0034, -74.3859
View on Maps ↗

Carpi Lake

📍 41.1104, -74.3549
View on Maps ↗

Cascade Lake

📍 41.2046, -74.3459
View on Maps ↗

Cedar Pond

📍 41.1082, -74.4253
View on Maps ↗

Charlotteburg Reservoir

📍 41.0265, -74.4324
View on Maps ↗

Cindy Linda Lake

📍 41.2266, -74.3110
View on Maps ↗

Clinton Reservoir

📍 41.0893, -74.4511
View on Maps ↗

Cranberry Pond

📍 41.1416, -74.2031
View on Maps ↗

Deer Trail Lake

📍 41.1177, -74.5282
View on Maps ↗

Eagle Lake

📍 41.1527, -74.2365
View on Maps ↗

Echo Lake

📍 41.0598, -74.4088
View on Maps ↗

Erskine Lake

📍 41.0938, -74.2537
View on Maps ↗

Fawn Lake

📍 41.1147, -74.5270
View on Maps ↗

Forest Hill Lake

📍 41.0283, -74.3971
View on Maps ↗

Fountain Spring Lake

📍 41.0632, -74.2674
View on Maps ↗

Fox Trail Lake

📍 41.0452, -74.5682
View on Maps ↗

Glenmere Lake

📍 41.3244, -74.3369
View on Maps ↗

Glenwood Lake

📍 41.2294, -74.5168
View on Maps ↗

Goshen Number Two Reservoir

📍 41.3680, -74.3165
View on Maps ↗

Goshen Reservoir

📍 41.3775, -74.3301
View on Maps ↗

Green Ridge Lake

📍 41.0414, -74.5920
View on Maps ↗

Heaters Pond

📍 41.0692, -74.5847
View on Maps ↗

Henion Pond

📍 41.0223, -74.3648
View on Maps ↗

Hoppers Lake

📍 41.0019, -74.2417
View on Maps ↗

Kings Pond

📍 41.0106, -74.2071
View on Maps ↗

Lake Arkin

📍 41.3463, -74.5929
View on Maps ↗

Lake Rickonda

📍 41.1119, -74.3044
View on Maps ↗

Lake Stockholm

📍 41.0683, -74.5297
View on Maps ↗

Lake Swannanoa

📍 41.0089, -74.5197
View on Maps ↗

Lindy Lake

📍 41.0770, -74.3714
View on Maps ↗

MacMillan Reservoir

📍 41.0855, -74.2032
View on Maps ↗

Macopin Reservoir

📍 41.0215, -74.4039
View on Maps ↗

Maple Lake

📍 41.0059, -74.3682
View on Maps ↗

Melody Lake

📍 41.1128, -74.3694
View on Maps ↗

Moosepac Pond

📍 41.0279, -74.5039
View on Maps ↗

Moosepac Pond

📍 41.0244, -74.5066
View on Maps ↗

Moosepac Pond

📍 41.0262, -74.5067
View on Maps ↗

Mud Pond

📍 41.1410, -74.5163
View on Maps ↗

Nosenzo Pond

📍 41.0823, -74.3825
View on Maps ↗

Oak Ridge Reservoir

📍 41.0567, -74.4997
View on Maps ↗

Pettet Pond

📍 41.1145, -74.3890
View on Maps ↗

Pinecliff Reservoir

📍 41.1378, -74.3864
View on Maps ↗

Pleasant Valley Lake

📍 41.1808, -74.5504
View on Maps ↗

Ridgebury Lake

📍 41.3864, -74.4491
View on Maps ↗

Sandy Beach Lake

📍 41.1658, -74.2697
View on Maps ↗

Schaffers Ponds

📍 41.0557, -74.4672
View on Maps ↗

Silver Lake

📍 41.1215, -74.5325
View on Maps ↗

Snow Valley Pond

📍 41.0733, -74.4355
View on Maps ↗

Sparta Lake

📍 41.0459, -74.5624
View on Maps ↗

Summit Lake

📍 41.0994, -74.5354
View on Maps ↗

Tamarack Lake

📍 41.0938, -74.5388
View on Maps ↗

Terrace Lake

📍 41.0100, -74.3599
View on Maps ↗

Triangle Lake

📍 41.0826, -74.4920
View on Maps ↗

Upper Blauvelt Lake

📍 41.0017, -74.2291
View on Maps ↗

Upper Mount Glen Lake

📍 41.0733, -74.3677
View on Maps ↗

Vitale Pond

📍 41.0053, -74.2179
View on Maps ↗

Wallkill Lake

📍 41.2367, -74.5356
View on Maps ↗

Walton Lake

📍 41.3062, -74.2214
View on Maps ↗

Warwick Reservoir

📍 41.2306, -74.3614
View on Maps ↗

West Milford Lake

📍 41.1302, -74.3631
View on Maps ↗

Willow Lake

📍 41.3545, -74.5740
View on Maps ↗

Wonder Lake

📍 41.0335, -74.3907
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.

Many of the larger lakes in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.

The Elm Lake Area Fishing Spots includes 174 documented fishing locations across New York. These range from small ponds and streams to large lakes, providing options for every skill level.