New Jersey Fishing

Butler Reservoir

Known for its prized fishing reputation, Butler Reservoir in the eastern part of New Jersey attracts New Jersey enthusiasts. Butler Reservoir is located near the eastern part of New Jersey at coordinates 40.98, -74.37. The prized reservoir offers depth variation and structure that Largemouth Bass rely on. Local anglers frequently report success with Largemouth Bass, Crappie, Catfish at Butler Reservoir.

Reservoir New Jersey 40.9800, -74.3700
Updated 2026-04-29

Location

View on Google Maps 40.9800, -74.3700

Target Species

Largemouth BassLargemouth BassCrappieCrappieCatfishCatfish

Fishing Tips

  • Focus on grass beds during dawn when Largemouth Bass are active.
  • Focus on submerged ridges during dawn when Largemouth Bass are active.
  • Focus on primary points during late evening when Largemouth Bass are active.

Fishing Techniques for Butler Reservoir

Local forage and water conditions dictate the best approach. Clear water calls for natural colors and lighter line; stained water favors chartreuse, white, and vibrating baits. Pay attention to water temperature — it drives fish positioning more than any other factor at this reservoir.

What to Expect at Butler Reservoir

Fishing pressure is moderate year-round, peaking on weekends and holidays from spring through fall. Weekday trips typically mean fewer crowds and better fishing. The ecosystem here supports healthy populations of Largemouth Bass and Crappie, with good catch rates for prepared anglers.

Regulations

Anglers must obtain a New Jersey fishing license. New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife enforces bag limits and size restrictions.

Fishing Tips for Butler Reservoir

Carters Pond

Cantys Lake

Cold Spring Lake

Frequently Asked Questions

Live bait such as live shiners works well. Many anglers also use artificial lures.

Check with New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife for specific regulations. Common restrictions include slot limits and bag limits.

Largemouth Bass here respond well to both live bait and artificial lures. Focus on structure.