New York Fishing

Arbuckle Pond

Situated in the eastern part of New York, Arbuckle Pond is a quality Lake that attracts dedicated anglers pursuing Largemouth Bass, Walleye, Northern Pike. Arbuckle Pond is located near the eastern part of New York at coordinates 44.52, -74.92. The quality lake provides stable water levels and diverse habitat for Largemouth Bass, Walleye, Northern Pike. Local anglers frequently report success with Largemouth Bass, Walleye, Northern Pike at Arbuckle Pond.

Lake New York 44.5200, -74.9200
Updated 2026-04-29

Location

View on Google Maps 44.5200, -74.9200

Target Species

Largemouth BassLargemouth BassWalleyeWalleyeNorthern PikeNorthern Pike

Fishing Tips

  • Focus on bridge pilings during late evening when Largemouth Bass are active.
  • Focus on rock humps during first light when Largemouth Bass are active.
  • Focus on dam faces during dusk when Largemouth Bass are active.

Fishing Techniques for Arbuckle Pond

Medium-action spinning gear paired with 8-12 lb test line covers most situations at this lake. Soft plastics, crankbaits, and live bait rigs all produce consistent results depending on conditions. For Largemouth Bass, try matching the local forage — shad, bluegill, or crawfish patterns work well here.

What to Expect at Arbuckle Pond

Take time to read the water when you arrive — baitfish activity, bird movement, and surface disturbances all signal where fish are feeding. The character of this lake changes with the seasons, so repeat visits often reveal new patterns and productive spots you missed before.

Regulations

A valid New York fishing license is required. Check New York Department of Environmental Conservation for current regulations.

Fishing Tips for Arbuckle Pond

Allen Falls Reservoir

Arquett Pond

Antediluvian Pond

Frequently Asked Questions

Depth varies across Arbuckle Pond. Scout shallow areas and deeper channels for best results.

Many areas of Arbuckle Pond allow wade fishing. Check conditions and regulations before heading out.