New Mexico Fishing

Nicoll Lake

The magnificent waters of Nicoll Lake in western New Mexico, New Mexico, provide a scenic backdrop for catching Rainbow Trout, Largemouth Bass, Kokanee Salmon. Nicoll Lake is located near western New Mexico at coordinates 34.95, -108.38. The magnificent lake provides stable water levels and diverse habitat for Rainbow Trout, Largemouth Bass, Kokanee Salmon. Local anglers frequently report success with Rainbow Trout, Largemouth Bass, Kokanee Salmon at Nicoll Lake.

Lake New Mexico 34.9500, -108.3800
Updated 2026-04-29

Location

View on Google Maps 34.9500, -108.3800

Target Species

Rainbow TroutRainbow TroutLargemouth BassLargemouth BassKokanee SalmonKokanee Salmon

Fishing Tips

  • Focus on shallow flats during dawn when Rainbow Trout are active.
  • Focus on lily pads during dawn when Rainbow Trout are active.
  • Focus on submerged timber during first light when Rainbow Trout are active.

Fishing Techniques for Nicoll Lake

Local forage and water conditions dictate the best approach. Clear water calls for natural colors and lighter line; stained water favors chartreuse, white, and vibrating baits. Pay attention to water temperature — it drives fish positioning more than any other factor at this lake.

What to Expect at Nicoll Lake

Fishing pressure is moderate year-round, peaking on weekends and holidays from spring through fall. Weekday trips typically mean fewer crowds and better fishing. The ecosystem here supports healthy populations of Rainbow Trout and Largemouth Bass, with good catch rates for prepared anglers.

Regulations

New Mexico fishing license required. Verify regulations with New Mexico Department of Game and Fish before fishing.

Fishing Tips for Nicoll Lake

Dog Lake

Big Lake

Monument Lake

Frequently Asked Questions

Check with New Mexico Department of Game and Fish for specific regulations. Common restrictions include slot limits and bag limits.

Rainbow Trout here respond well to both live bait and artificial lures. Focus on structure.

Many anglers access Nicoll Lake by boat. Verify local access restrictions before your trip.