New Jersey Fishing

Butterfly Pond

Butterfly Pond has earned its reputation as a beautiful Lake destination among New Jersey fishing communities. Butterfly Pond is located near the eastern part of New Jersey at coordinates 40.53, -74.17. The beautiful lake provides stable water levels and diverse habitat for Largemouth Bass, Walleye, Northern Pike. Local anglers frequently report success with Largemouth Bass, Walleye, Northern Pike at Butterfly Pond.

Lake New Jersey 40.5300, -74.1700
Updated 2026-04-29

Location

View on Google Maps 40.5300, -74.1700

Fishing Tips

  • Focus on shallow flats during dusk when Largemouth Bass are active.
  • Focus on shoreline drop-offs during sunset hours when Largemouth Bass are active.
  • Focus on dam faces during dawn when Largemouth Bass are active.

Fishing Techniques for Butterfly Pond

Seasonal patterns here follow typical New Jersey trends: pre-spawn activity peaks in early spring, summer fishing is best during low-light periods, and fall brings aggressive feeding before winter. Each season favors different presentations, so adjust your tackle accordingly.

What to Expect at Butterfly Pond

Take time to read the water when you arrive — baitfish activity, bird movement, and surface disturbances all signal where fish are feeding. The character of this lake changes with the seasons, so repeat visits often reveal new patterns and productive spots you missed before.

Regulations

Anglers must obtain a New Jersey fishing license. New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife enforces bag limits and size restrictions.

Fishing Tips for Butterfly Pond

Frequently Asked Questions

Largemouth Bass here respond well to both live bait and artificial lures. Focus on structure.

Many anglers access Butterfly Pond by boat. Verify local access restrictions before your trip.

Essential items: fishing license, appropriate tackle for Largemouth Bass, sun protection, water.