← Ohio Fishing

Fay Lake Area Fishing Spots

42 Fishing Spots

Covering a diverse stretch of Ohio, the Fay Lake Area Fishing Spots is home to 42 unique fishing locations. This area features 36 deep reservoirs and 6 well-stocked lakes, offering anglers the chance to target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish across varied habitats and conditions.

The region's diverse aquatic habitats support robust fish populations year-round. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Experienced guides in the area suggest adapting your approach based on seasonal patterns and water temperature changes.

Tackle selection for this zone should account for the variety of water types present. Medium-action spinning rods work well for most reservoir fishing here, while heavier setups are recommended for larger species like catfish. Live bait — nightcrawlers, minnows, and cut shad — remains highly effective across all water types. For catch-and-release fishing, barbless hooks and proper handling techniques help maintain the zone's healthy fish populations.

Anglers traveling to the Fay Lake Area Fishing Spots will find a range of amenities nearby. Bait and tackle shops, convenience stores, and gas stations are available in the surrounding communities. For the best experience, arrive early to secure parking at popular spots — especially on weekends during peak season. Pack sunscreen, insect repellent, and plenty of water, as some locations offer limited shade. A Ohio fishing license must be purchased before your trip and carried while fishing.

All 42 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Reservoirs (36)

Bassage Lake

40.2492, -80.8765
View full guide →

Boich Mining Company Pond Number One

40.3120, -80.7703
View full guide →

Boich Mining Company Pond Number Two

40.3166, -80.7727
View full guide →

Bowers Pond

40.4186, -80.8021
View full guide →

Cadiz Country Club Lake

40.2515, -80.9902
View full guide →

Cardinal Fly Ash Retention Reservoir

40.2726, -80.6451
View full guide →

Consolidation Coal Company Pond 0107-

40.2049, -80.9482
View full guide →

Consolidation Coal Company Pond 0206

40.3291, -80.8197
View full guide →

Consolidation Coal Company Pond 0207

40.3008, -80.8902
View full guide →

Consolidation Coal Company Pond 0207

40.3035, -80.8891
View full guide →

Crawford Pond

40.3169, -80.9209
View on Maps ↗

Croskey Pond

40.2651, -80.9305
View on Maps ↗

Fay Lake

40.3956, -80.9576
View on Maps ↗

Friendship Park Lake

40.2834, -80.7808
View on Maps ↗

Georgetown Plant Lower Supply Pond

40.2327, -80.9988
View on Maps ↗

Georgetown Plant Upper Supply Pond

40.2237, -80.9964
View on Maps ↗

Georgetown Prep Plant Freshwater Lake

40.2416, -80.9423
View on Maps ↗

Georgetown Upper Dam Number One Pond

40.2197, -80.9548
View on Maps ↗

Georgetown Upper Dam Number Two Pond

40.2164, -80.9643
View on Maps ↗

Jefferson Lake

40.4623, -80.7977
View on Maps ↗

Jefferson Sportsmens Lake Number One

40.3288, -80.7975
View on Maps ↗

Jefferson Sportsmens Lake Number Three

40.3363, -80.8038
View on Maps ↗

Jefferson Sportsmens Lake Number Two

40.3335, -80.8005
View on Maps ↗

Mader Pond

40.3808, -80.8743
View on Maps ↗

Malabu Lake

40.2742, -80.7495
View on Maps ↗

Mingo Sportsmens Club Lake Number

40.3100, -80.7407
View on Maps ↗

Mingo Sportsmens Club Lake Number

40.3149, -80.7521
View on Maps ↗

Pine Valley Sportsmens Lake Number

40.2787, -80.8729
View on Maps ↗

Pine Valley Sportsmens Lake Number

40.2804, -80.8649
View on Maps ↗

Pine Valley Sportsmens Lake Number

40.2882, -80.8754
View on Maps ↗

Rod Lake

40.5392, -80.8402
View on Maps ↗

Saint John Vianney Seminary Lake

40.3885, -80.8134
View on Maps ↗

Schaney Pond

40.3216, -80.9589
View on Maps ↗

Seleski Pond

40.2447, -80.9349
View on Maps ↗

Smithfield Lions Club Lake

40.2833, -80.8168
View on Maps ↗

Sparrow Reservoir

40.2759, -80.9741
View on Maps ↗

Lakes (6)

Brandywine Lake

40.4706, -80.6517
View full guide →

Kilgore Lake

40.5295, -80.9657
View on Maps ↗

Lake Betsy

40.3096, -80.7472
View on Maps ↗

Lake George

40.5222, -80.8318
View on Maps ↗

Sunset Lake

40.4239, -80.7439
View on Maps ↗

Varkony Pond

40.3168, -80.9149
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Many of the larger reservoirs in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.

The Fay Lake Area Fishing Spots includes 42 documented fishing locations across Ohio. These range from small ponds and streams to large reservoirs, providing options for every skill level.

Yes, a valid Ohio fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the Ohio wildlife agency or at local bait shops.