← Back to New York

Forest Lake Area Fishing Spots

41 Fishing Spots New York

Anglers exploring the Forest Lake Area Fishing Spots in New York will discover 41 fishing destinations spanning 23 nutrient-rich lakes and 18 reliable reservoirs. This region is particularly noted for its Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish fisheries, drawing both local enthusiasts and traveling anglers.

Local fishing conditions here are shaped by the region's geography and climate patterns. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Many of these spots see less pressure than more well-known destinations, offering a more intimate fishing experience.

Experienced anglers in New York recommend matching your technique to the specific water conditions in this zone. During warmer months, topwater action can be explosive at dawn and dusk on the lakes. As water temperatures drop, transitioning to slower presentations like jigs and drop-shot rigs produces consistent catches. Ice fishing is available during winter months in the northern portions, targeting panfish and walleye through the ice.

Most fishing spots in the Forest Lake Area Fishing Spots are accessible via paved roads, with many offering designated parking areas and clear trails to the water. Public boat ramps are available at the larger lakes, typically with no launch fee or a nominal daily charge. Several spots also have accessible fishing piers, making them suitable for anglers with mobility limitations. Cell service can be spotty in the more remote areas of this zone, so downloading offline maps before your trip is recommended.

All 41 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (23)

Baker Pond

📍 42.8522, -72.4661
View full guide →

Brickyard Pond

📍 42.9235, -72.2796
View on Maps ↗

Cass Pond

📍 42.7459, -72.2644
View on Maps ↗

Deane Pond

📍 42.6601, -72.5226
View on Maps ↗

Forest Lake

📍 42.7931, -72.3667
View on Maps ↗

Hale Pond

📍 42.8065, -72.4062
View on Maps ↗

Hastings Pond

📍 42.6725, -72.3305
View on Maps ↗

Ice Pond

📍 42.8624, -72.5752
View on Maps ↗

Indian Pond

📍 42.8578, -72.5258
View on Maps ↗

Kilburn Pond

📍 42.8344, -72.4720
View on Maps ↗

Lily Pond

📍 42.9244, -72.4854
View on Maps ↗

Long Pond

📍 42.6721, -72.2101
View on Maps ↗

Mud Pond

📍 42.7689, -72.3044
View on Maps ↗

Newell Pond

📍 42.6356, -72.5750
View on Maps ↗

Otter Pond

📍 42.6544, -72.5333
View on Maps ↗

Royalston Road Pond

📍 42.6401, -72.2408
View on Maps ↗

Sandy Pond

📍 42.7800, -72.2860
View on Maps ↗

Sawyer Ponds

📍 42.6929, -72.4883
View on Maps ↗

Shadow Lake

📍 42.6712, -72.4894
View on Maps ↗

Spot Meadow Pond

📍 42.8138, -72.3922
View on Maps ↗

Streeter Pond

📍 42.6817, -72.4931
View on Maps ↗

Swanzey Lake

📍 42.8440, -72.3030
View on Maps ↗

Upper Wilson Pond

📍 42.9104, -72.2563
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (18)

Chestnut Hill Reservoir

📍 42.8544, -72.5665
View on Maps ↗

Fullam Pond

📍 42.8521, -72.4278
View on Maps ↗

Gales Pond

📍 42.6682, -72.3125
View on Maps ↗

Grandin Reservoir

📍 42.7200, -72.4213
View on Maps ↗

Hubner Pond

📍 42.8711, -72.4679
View on Maps ↗

Maynard Pond

📍 42.6125, -72.5780
View on Maps ↗

Northfield Mountain Reservoir

📍 42.6144, -72.4434
View on Maps ↗

Otter Brook Lake

📍 42.9544, -72.2355
View on Maps ↗

Robinhood Park Reservoir

📍 42.9377, -72.2646
View on Maps ↗

Rodgers Pond

📍 42.9920, -72.3148
View on Maps ↗

Sawyer Pond

📍 42.6915, -72.4887
View on Maps ↗

Shadow Lake

📍 42.9445, -72.3208
View on Maps ↗

Vernon Hatchery Pond

📍 42.7426, -72.4988
View on Maps ↗

West Hill Reservoir

📍 42.8159, -72.2041
View on Maps ↗

Wheelers Pond

📍 42.6232, -72.3272
View on Maps ↗

Whites Pond

📍 42.6404, -72.2682
View on Maps ↗

Williams Pond

📍 42.6411, -72.2815
View on Maps ↗

Wilson Pond

📍 42.9013, -72.2621
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.

Many of the larger lakes in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.