← Back to New York

Mud Pond Area Fishing Spots

109 Fishing Spots New York

The Mud Pond Area Fishing Spots in New York encompasses 109 fishing destinations, including 64 vast reservoirs and 45 hidden lakes. Anglers visiting this region can expect productive waters holding Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish, with opportunities ranging from quiet shore fishing to adventurous boat outings.

Local fishing conditions here are shaped by the region's geography and climate patterns. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Many of these spots see less pressure than more well-known destinations, offering a more intimate fishing experience.

Experienced anglers in New York recommend matching your technique to the specific water conditions in this zone. During warmer months, topwater action can be explosive at dawn and dusk on the reservoirs. As water temperatures drop, transitioning to slower presentations like jigs and drop-shot rigs produces consistent catches. Ice fishing is available during winter months in the northern portions, targeting panfish and walleye through the ice.

Anglers traveling to the Mud Pond Area Fishing Spots will find a range of amenities nearby. Bait and tackle shops, convenience stores, and gas stations are available in the surrounding communities. For the best experience, arrive early to secure parking at popular spots — especially on weekends during peak season. Pack sunscreen, insect repellent, and plenty of water, as some locations offer limited shade. A New York fishing license must be purchased before your trip and carried while fishing.

All 109 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Reservoirs (64)

Asnacomet Pond

📍 42.4558, -71.9829
View full guide →

Asnebumskit Pond

📍 42.3233, -71.9089
View full guide →

Barre Town Reservoir

📍 42.4397, -72.1149
View full guide →

Bates Powers Reservoir

📍 42.5668, -72.1591
View on Maps ↗

Beagle Pond

📍 42.5870, -72.0055
View on Maps ↗

Beaudry Pond

📍 42.2295, -72.1827
View on Maps ↗

Bents Pond

📍 42.5273, -71.9990
View on Maps ↗

Betty Pond

📍 42.5646, -72.0999
View on Maps ↗

Brookhaven Lake

📍 42.2602, -72.1886
View on Maps ↗

Brown Pond

📍 42.4943, -72.1659
View on Maps ↗

Browning Pond

📍 42.3149, -71.9971
View on Maps ↗

Buckhill Pond

📍 42.2907, -71.9863
View on Maps ↗

Burnt Millpond

📍 42.5451, -71.9345
View on Maps ↗

Carter Pond

📍 42.4353, -72.1836
View on Maps ↗

Cedar Meadow Pond

📍 42.2280, -71.9410
View on Maps ↗

City Pond

📍 42.2449, -71.8841
View on Maps ↗

Comins Pond

📍 42.2033, -72.1957
View on Maps ↗

Cross Pond

📍 42.4735, -71.9546
View on Maps ↗

Dean Pond

📍 42.3473, -72.0276
View on Maps ↗

Doane Pond

📍 42.2864, -72.0734
View on Maps ↗

Dutton Pond

📍 42.2376, -71.9206
View on Maps ↗

Eames Pond

📍 42.3185, -71.9525
View on Maps ↗

Gaston Pond

📍 42.4561, -72.1306
View on Maps ↗

Greenville Pond

📍 42.2060, -71.9215
View on Maps ↗

Greenwood Pond

📍 42.5556, -71.9520
View on Maps ↗

Henshaw Pond

📍 42.2315, -71.8936
View on Maps ↗

Hilchey Pond

📍 42.5939, -72.0303
View on Maps ↗

Holden Reservoir Number One

📍 42.3120, -71.8772
View on Maps ↗

Holden Reservoir Number Two

📍 42.3007, -71.8687
View on Maps ↗

Horse Pond

📍 42.2939, -72.0705
View on Maps ↗

Horse Pond Brook Reservoir

📍 42.2802, -72.0437
View on Maps ↗

Kettle Brook Reservoir Number One

📍 42.2589, -71.8915
View on Maps ↗

Kettle Brook Reservoir Number Three

📍 42.2858, -71.9120
View on Maps ↗

Kettle Brook Reservoir Number Two

📍 42.2738, -71.9028
View on Maps ↗

Lake Whittemore

📍 42.2541, -71.9847
View on Maps ↗

Lovewell Pond

📍 42.5108, -71.9572
View on Maps ↗

Maple Spring Pond

📍 42.3771, -71.8822
View on Maps ↗

Mare Meadow Reservoir North

📍 42.5154, -71.9324
View on Maps ↗

Meetinghouse Pond

📍 42.5343, -71.9095
View on Maps ↗

Minott Pond

📍 42.5362, -71.9611
View on Maps ↗

Moulton Pond

📍 42.3899, -71.9542
View on Maps ↗

Murdock Pond

📍 42.5706, -71.9660
View on Maps ↗

Muschopauge Pond

📍 42.3833, -71.9225
View on Maps ↗

Newton Reservoir

📍 42.5984, -72.1759
View on Maps ↗

Noyes Pond

📍 42.5054, -71.9137
View on Maps ↗

Otter River Reservoir

📍 42.5950, -72.0490
View on Maps ↗

Parker Pond

📍 42.5798, -72.0125
View on Maps ↗

Partridge Pond

📍 42.5386, -71.9394
View on Maps ↗

Partridgeville Pond

📍 42.5440, -72.0441
View on Maps ↗

Phillipston Reservoir

📍 42.5785, -72.1768
View on Maps ↗

Powder Mill Pond

📍 42.3897, -72.0753
View on Maps ↗

Reservoir Number 1

📍 42.5767, -72.1863
View on Maps ↗

Ridgley Pond

📍 42.5764, -72.0499
View on Maps ↗

Sargent Pond

📍 42.2488, -71.9165
View on Maps ↗

Smith Reservoir

📍 42.5265, -71.8925
View on Maps ↗

Snows Millpond

📍 42.5600, -71.8553
View on Maps ↗

Southwick Pond

📍 42.2843, -71.8913
View on Maps ↗

Stoneville Reservoir

📍 42.2080, -71.8596
View on Maps ↗

Travers Pond

📍 42.5579, -71.9851
View on Maps ↗

Upper Reservoir

📍 42.5364, -71.9666
View on Maps ↗

Waite Pond

📍 42.5146, -71.9824
View on Maps ↗

Watson Millpond

📍 42.2164, -71.9602
View on Maps ↗

Wax Factory Pond

📍 42.4770, -72.0765
View on Maps ↗

Wrights Reservoir

📍 42.5443, -71.9694
View on Maps ↗

Lakes (45)

Beaudry Pond

📍 42.2256, -72.1678
View on Maps ↗

Bennett Pond

📍 42.5006, -72.0215
View on Maps ↗

Black Pond

📍 42.4696, -71.9036
View on Maps ↗

Bliss Pond

📍 42.2713, -72.1157
View on Maps ↗

Bolton Pond

📍 42.5054, -71.8971
View on Maps ↗

Bouchard Pond

📍 42.2205, -71.9345
View on Maps ↗

Carter Pond

📍 42.2696, -72.1966
View on Maps ↗

Claypit Pond

📍 42.2234, -72.0544
View on Maps ↗

Cook Pond

📍 42.5330, -72.0534
View on Maps ↗

Crystal Lake

📍 42.5878, -71.9928
View on Maps ↗

Crystal Pond

📍 42.2972, -71.8605
View on Maps ↗

Davis Pond

📍 42.3473, -72.0466
View on Maps ↗

Dyer Pond

📍 42.5603, -71.9917
View on Maps ↗

Echo Lake

📍 42.4777, -71.8886
View on Maps ↗

Farm Pond

📍 42.4568, -71.9049
View on Maps ↗

Farm Pond

📍 42.5867, -71.9396
View on Maps ↗

Foley Pond

📍 42.3219, -72.0380
View on Maps ↗

Greenwood Pond

📍 42.5541, -72.0413
View on Maps ↗

Gristmill Pond

📍 42.3129, -71.9584
View on Maps ↗

Howe Pond

📍 42.2135, -71.9992
View on Maps ↗

Kendall Pond

📍 42.5629, -72.0182
View on Maps ↗

Lamb City Pond

📍 42.5778, -72.1367
View on Maps ↗

Mill Pond

📍 42.3593, -71.8831
View on Maps ↗

Mud Pond

📍 42.2270, -72.0571
View on Maps ↗

Muzzy Lake

📍 42.2414, -71.9901
View on Maps ↗

Natty Pond

📍 42.4937, -72.0237
View on Maps ↗

Otter Pond

📍 42.4587, -71.8977
View on Maps ↗

Paige Pond

📍 42.5874, -72.1923
View on Maps ↗

Peg Millpond

📍 42.3598, -72.0416
View on Maps ↗

Penn Central Pond

📍 42.2209, -72.0246
View on Maps ↗

Perry Pond

📍 42.2319, -72.0569
View on Maps ↗

Quad Pond

📍 42.5674, -71.9570
View on Maps ↗

Rice Meadow Pond

📍 42.5374, -71.8654
View on Maps ↗

Rock Fire Pond

📍 42.4506, -71.9121
View on Maps ↗

Sawmill Pond

📍 42.3124, -71.9589
View on Maps ↗

Shaw Pond

📍 42.2597, -71.9391
View on Maps ↗

Smiths Pond

📍 42.2408, -71.8693
View on Maps ↗

Snake Pond

📍 42.5559, -72.0160
View on Maps ↗

Streeter Pond

📍 42.3360, -71.9089
View on Maps ↗

Stump Pond

📍 42.5810, -71.9727
View on Maps ↗

Turkey Hill Pond

📍 42.3363, -71.9481
View on Maps ↗

Waite Pond

📍 42.2493, -71.8911
View on Maps ↗

Whitehall Pond

📍 42.3708, -71.9950
View on Maps ↗

Wickaboag Pond

📍 42.2453, -72.1543
View on Maps ↗

Wildlife Pond

📍 42.4548, -71.9025
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Many of the larger reservoirs in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.