← New York Fishing

Best Lake Area Fishing Spots

156 Fishing Spots

The Best Lake Area Fishing Spots offers 156 fishing opportunities across New York's 111 hidden lakes and 45 scenic reservoirs. Whether you're chasing Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish or simply looking for a peaceful day on the water, this region delivers.

This zone's proximity to multiple water types means anglers can plan multi-day trips targeting different species each day. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. The combination of access, fish diversity, and scenic beauty makes it a standout region.

Experienced anglers in New York recommend matching your technique to the specific water conditions in this zone. During warmer months, topwater action can be explosive at dawn and dusk on the lakes. As water temperatures drop, transitioning to slower presentations like jigs and drop-shot rigs produces consistent catches. Ice fishing is available during winter months in the northern portions, targeting panfish and walleye through the ice.

Access to the fishing waters in this zone is generally very good, with a mix of public lands, state wildlife areas, and municipal parks providing entry points. Be aware that some smaller waters may be surrounded by private property — always verify access rights and look for posted signs. The best local advice comes from nearby bait shops, where staff can point you toward the current hot bite and steer you away from areas that are unfishable due to low water or other seasonal conditions.

All 156 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (111)

2 Gatehall Drive Pond

40.8480, -74.4668
View full guide →

Ancients Pond

40.9667, -74.2120
View full guide →

Baker Mill Pond

40.9036, -74.5987
View full guide →

Barbour Pond

40.9612, -74.2300
View full guide →

Barton Pond

40.8818, -74.4675
View full guide →

Beaver Pond

40.9578, -74.4733
View on Maps ↗

Bee Meadow Pond

40.8349, -74.4147
View on Maps ↗

Bee Meadow Pond

40.8336, -74.4103
View on Maps ↗

Best Lake

40.6394, -74.4488
View on Maps ↗

Bloodgoods Pond

40.6303, -74.2977
View on Maps ↗

Botts Pond

40.9439, -74.3689
View on Maps ↗

Breen's Pond

40.9958, -74.2929
View on Maps ↗

Briant Pond

40.7153, -74.3358
View on Maps ↗

Cabin Lake

40.8785, -74.4573
View on Maps ↗

Cat Swamp Pond

40.7696, -74.5253
View on Maps ↗

Clark Pond

40.9011, -74.5464
View on Maps ↗

Clover Hill Pond

40.6598, -74.5198
View on Maps ↗

Cooks Pond

40.9130, -74.4583
View on Maps ↗

Cooper Pond

40.8924, -74.4613
View on Maps ↗

Country Club Ponds

40.9489, -74.2358
View on Maps ↗

Country Club Ponds

40.9481, -74.2337
View on Maps ↗

Crane's Mill Lake

40.8440, -74.3069
View on Maps ↗

Crestmere Lake

40.9650, -74.2825
View on Maps ↗

Crystal Lake

40.8005, -74.2478
View on Maps ↗

Dealaman Pond

40.6286, -74.5060
View on Maps ↗

Diamond Spring Pond

40.9013, -74.4672
View on Maps ↗

Duck Pond

40.7496, -74.2608
View on Maps ↗

Durham Pond

40.9942, -74.4461
View on Maps ↗

Egbert lake

40.9970, -74.4778
View on Maps ↗

Fern Lake

40.8787, -74.4613
View on Maps ↗

Fox's Pond

40.9066, -74.5173
View on Maps ↗

G-2 Pond

40.9589, -74.5214
View on Maps ↗

Gaeds Pond

40.9428, -74.2011
View on Maps ↗

Gatehall Drive Pond

40.8470, -74.4635
View on Maps ↗

Green Acres Pond

40.6173, -74.4388
View on Maps ↗

Grover Cleveland Pond

40.8340, -74.2877
View on Maps ↗

Hedden Pond

40.8785, -74.5788
View on Maps ↗

Hinchman Pond

40.9491, -74.2236
View on Maps ↗

Hollstein Lake

40.8888, -74.5010
View on Maps ↗

Horshoe Pond

40.6074, -74.4474
View on Maps ↗

Hussa Pond

40.8919, -74.4967
View on Maps ↗

Jackson Pond

40.6306, -74.2855
View on Maps ↗

Jones Pond

40.7916, -74.5063
View on Maps ↗

Kelley's Pond (at Brookside Grove)

40.7500, -74.3810
View on Maps ↗

Kitchell Pond

40.7679, -74.4554
View on Maps ↗

Koehler Pond

40.9513, -74.4328
View on Maps ↗

Koehler Pond

40.9459, -74.4362
View on Maps ↗

Lake Ames

40.9526, -74.5014
View on Maps ↗

Lake Emma

40.9841, -74.4796
View on Maps ↗

Lake Intervale

40.8908, -74.4214
View on Maps ↗

Lake Surprise

40.6893, -74.3750
View on Maps ↗

Lake Telemark

40.9599, -74.5001
View on Maps ↗

Lake Vincent

40.8031, -74.2624
View on Maps ↗

Lakeview Terriost Lake with waterfall

40.9145, -74.3528
View on Maps ↗

Laurel Pond

40.9886, -74.2680
View on Maps ↗

Lincoln Park Lake

40.9405, -74.2960
View on Maps ↗

Lionshead Lake

40.9738, -74.2586
View on Maps ↗

Little Mitten Lake

40.9868, -74.4530
View on Maps ↗

Little Pond

40.9414, -74.2279
View on Maps ↗

Little Seeley's Pond

40.6708, -74.4014
View on Maps ↗

Long Pond

40.7625, -74.4305
View on Maps ↗

Longwood Lake

40.9851, -74.5361
View on Maps ↗

Lower Echo Lake

40.6762, -74.3394
View on Maps ↗

Manor Lake

40.8823, -74.4273
View on Maps ↗

Masar Park Pond

40.9352, -74.4001
View on Maps ↗

McDonald's Ponds

40.9556, -74.2829
View on Maps ↗

McDonald's Ponds

40.9562, -74.2853
View on Maps ↗

Mendham Commons Pond

40.7873, -74.5936
View on Maps ↗

Mill Pond

40.8852, -74.2047
View on Maps ↗

Milton Lake

40.6080, -74.3007
View on Maps ↗

Mindowaskin Pond

40.6546, -74.3468
View on Maps ↗

Mirror Lake

40.8818, -74.4596
View on Maps ↗

Mirror Pond

40.8509, -74.4480
View on Maps ↗

Mount Hope Pond

40.9298, -74.5484
View on Maps ↗

Moxon Pond

40.6779, -74.3658
View on Maps ↗

Munsee Pond

40.6411, -74.2920
View on Maps ↗

New Pond

40.9867, -74.4236
View on Maps ↗

Noe Pond

40.7363, -74.4243
View on Maps ↗

North Pond

40.7363, -74.3221
View on Maps ↗

Openaki Lake

40.8557, -74.5279
View on Maps ↗

Packanack Lake

40.9397, -74.2556
View on Maps ↗

Pio Costa Lake

40.9359, -74.2920
View on Maps ↗

Rainbow Lake

40.8821, -74.4629
View on Maps ↗

Randall's Pond

40.9868, -74.2892
View on Maps ↗

Round Pond

40.7638, -74.4299
View on Maps ↗

Roveres Lake

40.9076, -74.2585
View on Maps ↗

Sawmill Pond

40.9728, -74.3332
View on Maps ↗

Seeley's Pond

40.6688, -74.4024
View on Maps ↗

Shackamaxon Lake

40.6294, -74.3529
View on Maps ↗

Silver Pond

40.7958, -74.4431
View on Maps ↗

Sokol Pond

40.9360, -74.4562
View on Maps ↗

South Pond

40.7358, -74.3249
View on Maps ↗

Speedwell Lake

40.8141, -74.4850
View on Maps ↗

Stillwell Pond

40.9572, -74.5241
View on Maps ↗

Stirling Lake

40.6771, -74.4945
View on Maps ↗

Suntan Lake

40.9911, -74.3285
View on Maps ↗

Swins' Ponds

40.9252, -74.2335
View on Maps ↗

Swins' Ponds

40.9261, -74.2326
View on Maps ↗

Swins' Ponds

40.9270, -74.2320
View on Maps ↗

Ted’s Pond

40.8466, -74.5540
View on Maps ↗

Tom's Lake

40.9576, -74.2592
View on Maps ↗

Twilight Lake

40.8802, -74.4564
View on Maps ↗

Upper Echo Lake

40.6736, -74.3457
View on Maps ↗

Upper Pond

40.9870, -74.2682
View on Maps ↗

Upper Rainbow Lake

40.8796, -74.4599
View on Maps ↗

Ursino Lake

40.6806, -74.2317
View on Maps ↗

Van Dorans Mill Pond

40.7339, -74.5436
View on Maps ↗

West Lake

40.9769, -74.3655
View on Maps ↗

Wildwood Lake

40.8948, -74.4342
View on Maps ↗

Wilson Pond

40.6366, -74.2672
View on Maps ↗

Woodland Lake

40.9595, -74.2859
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (45)

Birchwood Lake

40.8956, -74.4503
View on Maps ↗

Butler Reservoir

40.9835, -74.3737
View on Maps ↗

Campbells Pond

40.7374, -74.3041
View on Maps ↗

Canoe Brook Reservoir Number Three

40.7857, -74.3579
View on Maps ↗

Carters Pond

40.9764, -74.3953
View on Maps ↗

Cedar Grove Reservoir

40.8591, -74.2131
View on Maps ↗

Cedar Lake

40.9105, -74.4732
View on Maps ↗

Clyde Potts Reservoir

40.8069, -74.5839
View on Maps ↗

Dalrymple Pond

40.8542, -74.5798
View on Maps ↗

Deer Lake

40.9420, -74.4051
View on Maps ↗

Diamond Mill Pond

40.7322, -74.3070
View on Maps ↗

Dixons Pond

40.9382, -74.4435
View on Maps ↗

Dover Reservoir

40.8723, -74.5723
View on Maps ↗

Franklin Lake

40.9884, -74.2211
View on Maps ↗

Griffith Pond

40.9218, -74.4167
View on Maps ↗

Hood Pond

40.9182, -74.4202
View on Maps ↗

Jaqui Pond

40.8256, -74.4945
View on Maps ↗

Jays Pond

40.9681, -74.4019
View on Maps ↗

Lake Estling

40.8799, -74.4985
View on Maps ↗

Lake Hiawatha

40.8786, -74.3710
View on Maps ↗

Lake Juliet

40.9624, -74.4070
View on Maps ↗

Lake Montowac

40.9070, -74.3601
View on Maps ↗

Lake Reality

40.9709, -74.3730
View on Maps ↗

Lake Tumble-In

40.9240, -74.4360
View on Maps ↗

Lake Valhalla

40.9327, -74.3745
View on Maps ↗

Mount Hope Lake

40.9273, -74.5340
View on Maps ↗

Mount Kemble Lake

40.7428, -74.5241
View on Maps ↗

Mount Tabor Lake

40.8694, -74.4846
View on Maps ↗

Mountain Meadows Reservoir

40.8387, -74.5152
View on Maps ↗

Old Greystone Lower Reservoir

40.8380, -74.5029
View on Maps ↗

Old Greystone Upper Reservoir

40.8390, -74.5042
View on Maps ↗

Orange Reservoir

40.7638, -74.2860
View on Maps ↗

Point View Reservoir

40.9745, -74.2479
View on Maps ↗

Powder Mill Pond

40.8659, -74.4788
View on Maps ↗

Robinson's Branch Reservoir

40.6174, -74.3116
View on Maps ↗

Silver Lake

40.7529, -74.4712
View on Maps ↗

Spring Lake

40.7846, -74.4805
View on Maps ↗

Sunrise Lake

40.7879, -74.5451
View on Maps ↗

Sunset Lake

40.8885, -74.4537
View on Maps ↗

Surprise Lake

40.9541, -74.3542
View on Maps ↗

Taylortown Reservoir

40.9603, -74.3746
View on Maps ↗

Walrus Pond

40.8320, -74.4673
View on Maps ↗

Washington Pond

40.9038, -74.5822
View on Maps ↗

Watchung Lake

40.6355, -74.4556
View on Maps ↗

White Meadow Lake

40.9249, -74.5187
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.

The Best Lake Area Fishing Spots includes 156 documented fishing locations across New York. These range from small ponds and streams to large lakes, providing options for every skill level.

Many of the larger lakes in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.